Tuesday, December 18, 2012

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey - Full Review

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey - (December 14, 2012): PG-13

Distributor: Warner Bros. Pictures
                                      
Opening Weekend Box Office: #1 with $84,617,303

Domestic Box Office Gross to-date: $92,355,596

Gross Revenue: $230,555,596

Production Budget: N/A

Director: Peter Jackson
 
J.R.R. Tolkien fans the world over rejoiced when it was first announced that The Hobbit would be adapted into a prequel series, but Peter Jackson’s newest passion project wasn’t without a few setbacks, the most widely-known involving production delays caused by actor’s unions in New Zealand.  But after some savvy negotiations, the cameras were allowed to roll and Jackson was ready to film his multi-part epic back-to-back, returning several familiar faces to Middle-earth and testing a potentially revolutionary filmmaking format.  Based on the success of his previous fantasy epic film trilogy, there were no doubts that Lord of the Rings’ fans would return to theaters in droves, but Warner Bros. Pictures still executed strong marketing tactics to ensure that a new generation could appreciate an introduction to the Shire.  A fully-interactive website, dozens of contests, character posters, and even special menu items at Denny’s all kept buzz for this December release through the roof, and analyst all around Hollywood were predicting a record-breaking debut.  However, certain expectations had to be reigned-in, as there was going to be a noticeably tamer level of action this time around, and early critical reaction wasn’t exactly soaring; still, qualifications aside, I was still ecstatic to have my opening day, IMAX 3D ticket for An Unexpected Journey.

Set 60 years prior to the opening events of The Fellowship of The Ring, An Unexpected Journey finds young Hobbit Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) crossing paths with the infamous wizard Gandalf the Grey (Ian McKellen), who tricks the Halfling into hosting a dinner party for a ragtag group of Dwarves.  Soon enough, the group’s agenda is revealed by their leader, Thorin Oakenshield (Richard Armitage); with Gandalf’s help, the company of Dwarves intends to travel to the Lonely Mountain and reclaim a lost treasure that was taken years ago by the dangerous dragon, Smaug.  The Dwarves intend to recruit the Hobbit as a “burglar” in their journey, and though Bilbo is initially reluctant, the thrill of a potential adventure proves too enticing, and soon enough, he departs the Shire for the dangerous quest.  Though they are aided by allies like Elrond (Hugo Weaving), Galadriel (Cate Blanchett), and Saruman the White (Christopher Lee), the company must also contend with trolls, orcs, goblins, not to mention a mysterious creature that confronts Bilbo, carries a golden ring, and can only identify itself as Gollum (Andy Serkis).  As the true scope of their objective is revealed, Bilbo is forced to discover a level of bravery he never knew he possessed, a tool that will come in handy as the frightful dragon Smaug begins to awaken.

In terms of gorgeous landscapes, a fantastical story, and a sweeping score, An Unexpected Journey is a glorious return to Peter Jackson’s Middle-earth, but where The Hobbit really excels is in the performances of its main characters and the energy that pervades the narrative’s latter half.  Richard Armitage is surprisingly entertaining as Thorin, but as the lead protagonist, Martin Freeman delivers in the role of Bilbo, blending a mix of humor and internal conflict that makes him a far more interesting Hobbit to watch than Frodo was nearly a decade ago.  And speaking of Frodo, it was a welcome surprise to see Elijah Wood return in a cameo, along with so many other familiar faces from the original trilogy that help reinforce the shared universe between prequel and sequel, but no other character was more enjoyable to revisit than Gollum.  I may not remember some of the finer details of the original novel, but I cannot forget how much I enjoyed the “Riddles in the Dark” chapter, and An Unexpected Journey interprets this sequence brilliantly, focusing on Andy Serkis’ performance, adding new depth to an already complicated character, and providing a true treat for audiences.  Unfortunately, beyond the enjoyment of the core characters, the film still has some pretty glaring weaknesses that could not be overshadowed, even once the balance of momentum was achieved in the running time’s final hour.

In its entirety, I did enjoy The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, but given all of the hype surrounding the project, I was still disappointed in the overall lack of supporting character development, the noticeably uneven pacing, and the thoroughly distracting filming format.  Granted, it is one hell of a tall order to flesh out 13 Dwarves, but the film makes little effort to distinguish or let alone identify half of the characters; Fellowship of the Ring had nine main characters, and the audience loved every one of them, but at least a third of The Hobbit’s characters don’t even have distinguishable lines…how exactly are we supposed to get excited for their return in future installments?  And, I may have praised the exciting climax and conclusion to the film, but make no mistake, at nearly three hours with only a small fraction of the battles that helped define the franchise, things get slow, and things get boring.  Finally there’s the camerawork;  I understand that the 48 fps format isn’t required viewing, but for as much buzz as surrounded its usage, I absolutely hated the high-definition picture, which not only shattered the usual illusion of immersion, but also provided a picture so clear that action sequences were nauseating, while special effects and makeup looked both fake and low-budget.  So, even though none of the above-mentioned shortcomings are overly damning, I can only hope that they don’t reappear in the next two instillations of the planned trilogy.

As expected, An Unexpected Journey hit the box office like an absolute sledgehammer, earning $84.6 in its opening weekend, capturing the record for December opening but still falling short of the $100 million expectation that was predicted.  Add that impressive haul to the substantial foreign earnings and the expected large audiences of the Christmas and New Year’s holidays, and The Hobbit will have absolutely no trouble in setting even more financial records.  Now usually, at this point in the review, I compare earnings to production budget, but because The Hobbit trilogy is being filmed back-to-back, a total receipt has not yet become available, but no one at Warner Bros. has to worry about turning a profit.  With The Desolation of Smaug and There and Back Again hitting theaters in 2013 and 2014 respectively, we will be seeing plenty of Bilbo Baggins in the coming years, and by-and-large, it should be a rewarding experience, but I damn well sure won’t be seeing the next chapters in 48 fps.  In conclusion, even though I wasn’t overtly thrilled by The Hobbit, I can acknowledge that fans of Peter Jackson owe it to themselves to visit the theater, as long as their expectations don’t get too high.  

Overall Recommendation: Medium